Ferrous Sulfate vs. Other Iron Supplements: A Detailed Comparison

28 September 2025 0 Comments Liana Pendleton

Iron Supplement Selector

Select your preferences to get a recommended iron supplement:

Cost Priority: Stomach Tolerance: Medical Condition (if applicable):

When doctors prescribe iron, many patients wonder whether ferrous sulfate is really the best option or if another form might be gentler on the stomach, absorb better, or cost less. This guide walks you through the science, the practical differences, and the real‑world trade‑offs so you can pick the iron supplement that fits your lifestyle and health goals.

TL;DR - Quick Takeaways

Ferrous sulfate offers the highest elemental iron per tablet but often causes more GI upset.
Ferrous gluconate and ferrous fumarate provide slightly lower iron doses with milder side effects.
Iron bisglycinate and iron polysaccharide are “gentle‑release” formulas that many users tolerate well.
Heme iron polypeptide mimics the iron found in meat and yields the best absorption, but it’s pricier.
Pair any iron source with vitamin C and avoid calcium‑rich meals for optimal uptake.

What Is Ferrous Sulfate?

Ferrous Sulfate is a mineral salt that provides iron in the ferrous (Fe²⁺) form. Each 325mg tablet typically delivers about 65mg of elemental iron, making it one of the most concentrated over‑the‑counter iron sources. The supplement works by replenishing iron stores in the bone marrow, which in turn boosts hemoglobin production and alleviates the symptoms of iron‑deficiency anemia.

How Ferrous Sulfate Works in the Body

After you swallow a tablet, the acidic environment of the stomach reduces the iron from Fe³⁺ to Fe²⁺. This reduced form is then absorbed via the duodenal transporter DMT1 (divalent metal transporter‑1). From there, the iron travels through the bloodstream bound to transferrin, reaches the bone marrow, and gets incorporated into newly formed red blood cells.

Key Comparison Criteria

To decide whether ferrous sulfate or an alternative suits you best, look at five core factors:

Elemental iron content - how much usable iron each dose provides.
Absorption rate - the percentage of the dose that actually enters the bloodstream.
Gastrointestinal tolerance - frequency of nausea, constipation, or dark stools.
Cost per therapeutic dose - price you pay for the amount of iron needed to correct deficiency.
Interaction profile - foods, medications, or nutrients that boost or hinder uptake.

Alternative Iron Supplements

Below are the most common competitors you’ll see on pharmacy shelves or online.

Ferrous Gluconate delivers about 35mg of elemental iron per 300mg tablet, roughly half the dose of ferrous sulfate. Its slightly larger molecular weight makes it less aggressive on the stomach, so many users report fewer complaints of nausea or constipation.

Ferrous Fumarate offers around 106mg of elemental iron per 330mg tablet, giving a higher iron load than ferrous sulfate but in a form that some find marginally easier to tolerate.

Iron Bisglycinate (also called iron chelate) binds iron to two glycine molecules. This chelated complex shields the iron from stomach acid, leading to absorption rates as high as 90% and markedly fewer gastrointestinal side effects.

Iron Polysaccharide encapsulates iron particles within a carbohydrate matrix. The coating releases iron slowly throughout the intestine, which reduces irritation while still delivering a respectable 40mg of elemental iron per dose.

Heme Iron Polypeptide is derived from animal hemoglobin. Because it mimics the iron found in meat, the body absorbs it via the heme pathway-up to 30% more efficiently than non‑heme forms-making it a favorite for people with chronic malabsorption.

Side‑Effect Profile Across Options

Iron supplements share a common set of potential side effects, but the severity varies:

Ferrous sulfate: dark stools, constipation, nausea, and occasional abdominal cramping.
Ferrous gluconate: milder stomach upset; still can cause dark stools.
Ferrous fumarate: similar to sulfate but sometimes better tolerated.
Iron bisglycinate: lowest reported GI irritation; most users experience only a slight metallic taste.
Iron polysaccharide: minimal irritation thanks to delayed release.
Heme iron polypeptide: rare GI issues, but it may cause mild allergic reactions in those sensitive to animal proteins.

Cost Comparison (US retail, 2025)

Price per therapeutic iron dose (approx.)
Supplement	Elemental Iron / Dose	Typical Cost (USD)	Cost per mg of Elemental Iron
Ferrous Sulfate	65mg	$8 for 100 tablets	$0.12
Ferrous Gluconate	35mg	$10 for 100 tablets	$0.29
Ferrous Fumarate	106mg	$12 for 100 tablets	$0.11
Iron Bisglycinate	27mg	$18 for 60 capsules	$0.33
Iron Polysaccharide	40mg	$22 for 60 capsules	$0.55
Heme Iron Polypeptide	15mg	$35 for 30 capsules	$2.33

Food and Nutrient Interactions

Iron absorption gets a boost from Vitamin C, which converts ferric iron to the more absorbable ferrous state. A glass of orange juice or a squeeze of lemon can increase uptake by up to 70%.

Conversely, calcium (found in dairy), phytates (in whole grains), polyphenols (in tea and coffee), and certain antacids can hinder absorption. The safest rule is to take your iron supplement on an empty stomach or at least two hours away from these inhibitors.

Choosing the Right Iron Supplement for You

Here’s a quick decision tree you can follow:

If cost is your primary concern and you can tolerate mild GI upset, ferrous sulfate or ferrous fumarate are solid choices.
If you experience regular constipation or nausea, switch to ferrous gluconate or iron bisglycinate.
If you have a chronic malabsorption condition (e.g., celiac disease) or need the most efficient uptake, consider heme iron polypeptide, keeping budget in mind.
If you’re pregnant and want a balance of efficacy and tolerability, many obstetricians now recommend iron bisglycinate or iron polysaccharide combined with prenatal vitamins.

Practical Tips to Maximize Benefits

Take the supplement with a small amount of fruit juice (high in vitamin C).
Avoid coffee, tea, or calcium‑rich foods within an hour of dosing.
If stomach upset occurs, split your daily dose into two smaller portions.
Stay hydrated; constipation often improves with extra water.
Monitor iron levels with a blood test after 4‑6 weeks to adjust dosage.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I take ferrous sulfate and vitamin C together?

Yes. Vitamin C enhances the conversion of iron to its ferrous form, making absorption more efficient. A small glass of orange juice or a vitamin C tablet is enough.

Why does my stool turn black when I take iron?

Unabsorbed iron is excreted and oxidizes, giving stool a dark, almost tar‑like color. It’s harmless but can be alarming; just let your doctor know if it persists.

Is ferrous gluconate better for people with sensitive stomachs?

Generally, yes. Gluconate provides less elemental iron per tablet, which often translates to fewer gastrointestinal complaints.

How does heme iron differ from non‑heme iron?

Heme iron, found in animal meat, is absorbed intact via a separate transporter, bypassing many of the inhibitors that affect non‑heme sources like ferrous sulfate.

Can I take iron supplements while on a multivitamin?

Yes, but watch for calcium or zinc in the multivitamin, as they can compete with iron for absorption. Separate doses by a couple of hours if possible.

Bottom Line

Ferrous sulfate remains the most affordable and iron‑dense option, but its price of convenience is a higher likelihood of stomach upset. Alternatives like ferrous gluconate and iron bisglycinate trade a bit of elemental iron for better tolerability, while advanced formulas such as heme iron polypeptide offer top‑tier absorption at a premium price. By matching your health needs, budget, and tolerance level to the right formula-and by using vitamin C and timing tricks-you can correct iron deficiency without the frustration of side effects.